Monday, October 19, 2015

Textual Poaching


Artist's Statement:

For my textual poaching assignment, I wanted to find something pretty old, so I was looking through paintings. I stumbled upon Sower with Setting Sun by Vincent Van Gogh, which I’d never seen before, and immediately got an idea. The sower in his field reminded me of back when we first moved into the home I spent most my life in in Lakeville, MN. When we were first there, we had the only house in the neighborhood, surrounded by fields. It was very peaceful and rural looking, very like this painting. However, over time our neighborhood developed into a packed suburb, and the town itself grew, becoming a booming commercial center instead of a small farm town south of St. Paul. To illustrate this change, I put the power plant (representing pollution, etc.) and a commercial entity, Walmart, along with a suburban home, then finished it off with a nice road tearing straight through the beautiful field. I initially planned to make these pasted items look painted-in and a part of the canvas, but it was beyond my technical mastery; I think the final product turned out well regardless.

When talking about Star Trek and its legacy in our reading this week, Jenkins stated: “Intense interaction eventually leads many fans toward the creation of new texts, the writing of original stories.” I think that this can be true with other mediums, such as oil painting. While studying and thus mentally “interacting” with this Van Gogh work on such a personal level, I was drawn to create a new piece of work, however unpolished and poached it may be. Looking at this thing created by another man, I felt both inspired and obligated to do something with it beyond just think about it. In our discussion in class last Tuesday and Thursday, I definitely felt as if this was one of the paths we were setting ourselves upon – the road from an old creation to a new creation. This is something that is taught a lot in the film program, even in non-fiction production, as you have the discretion to take the stories happening in the world around you and tailor it to a message you wish to share or bring to light.


I think many people would argue against this concept from a practical standpoint, and I think rightfully so. Many people shy away from the idea of “ripping off” the work of others, not seeing how analogous it is with simply being inspired by them. When done incorrectly, it can certainly be harmful, such as literal plagiarism. However, when properly cited and/or referenced, a work you have “poached” becomes a small part of a new whole, such as a class paper or this assignment. It is not that I disrespect or wish to discredit Van Gogh. Contrarily, I believe I heavily credit his ability to speak to the soul by demonstrating how his work drove me to create “new texts” and give new meaning to a beautiful work of art.

No comments:

Post a Comment